- Greenshift Homepage
- Featured
- Compare
- 5paisa vs Upstox vs Shoonya
5paisa vs Upstox vs Shoonya
We will compare 5paisa vs Upstox vs Shoonya based on charges, account maintenance charges, investment options, customer service, user reviews, research and analysis, and the track record and reputation of the broker.
Company Overview
| |
|
Company name
|
5paisa
Upstox- RKSV Securities India Private Limited (RSIPL)
Shoonya by Finvasia |
|
Headquarters
|
Thane
Delhi
Mumbai |
|
Founder
|
Prakarsh Gagdani, Nirmal Jain
Ravi Kumar
Sarvjeet Singh Virk and Tajinder Singh Virk |
|
Establishment Year
|
2016
April 6, 2009
2009 |
Account opening & AMC
| |
|
Account Opening Fee
The account opening fee, also known as account setup charges, refers to the one-time charge levied by a brokerage firm when you open a new Demat and trading account to invest in securities like stocks, bonds, or ETFs. These fees can vary depending on the type of account, the brokerage firm, and any current promotions or offers. |
₹0
₹0
₹0 |
|
Annual Maintenance Charges (AMC)
This is a yearly fee levied by the depository participant (DP) to maintain your Demat account, where your shares are held electronically. |
₹300/year
₹0
₹0 |
Pledge Charges
| |
|
Pledge Creation Charges
|
₹50
₹20 + GST per scrip for Equity & ₹50 + GST per scrip for pledging Futures buy and sell and Options Sell orders only
₹20 |
|
Pledge Invocation Charges
|
₹0
₹50 + GST per scrip for unpledging
₹20 |
|
Interest on Margin Trading
|
0.06% Per Day
₹20/day for every slab of ₹40,000 taken as MTF
Does not provide |
|
Margin Re-Pledge
|
₹12.50 + GST per scrip
₹20 + GST per scrip for Equity
₹20 |
Brokerage charges & Fees
| |
|
Brokerage Plan
|
Regular Account
Standard
Standard account |
|
Equity Delivery Charges
|
₹20
₹20 or 2.5% whichever is lower
₹0 |
|
Equity Intraday Charges
|
₹20
₹20 per executed order or 0.05% (whichever is lower)
₹0 |
|
Equity Futures charges
|
₹20
₹20 per executed order or 0.05% (whichever is lower)
₹0 |
|
Equity Options charges
|
₹20
Flat ₹20 per executed order
₹0 |
|
Currency Futures charges
|
₹20
₹20 per executed order or 0.05% (whichever is lower)
₹0 |
|
Currency Options charges
|
₹20
Flat ₹20 per executed order
₹0 |
|
Commodity Futures charges
|
₹20
₹20 per executed order or 0.05% (whichever is lower)
₹0 |
|
Commodity Options charges
|
₹20
Flat ₹20 per executed order
₹0 |
Customer services offered
| |
|
Demat Services
|
✅Yes
✅Yes
✅Yes |
|
Trading Services
|
✅Yes
✅Yes
✅Yes |
|
Intraday Services
|
✅Yes
✅Yes
✅Yes |
|
F&O Services
|
✅Yes
✅Yes
✅Yes |
|
IPO Services
|
✅Yes
✅Yes
✅Yes |
|
Share Pledging
|
✅Yes
✅Yes
✅Yes |
|
NRI Services
|
⛔No
✅Yes
⛔No |
|
Referral Program
|
✅Yes
✅Yes
✅Yes |
Customer Support
| |
|
Call Support
|
089766 89766
022-41792999: All Trading Days – 8 am to 5 pm
+91 1726 750 000, +91 9779 097 777 |
|
Email Support
|
[email protected]
[email protected]: All Trading Days – 8 am to 5 pm
[email protected] |
|
Whatsapp Support
|
⛔No
No
⛔ No |
|
Website Support
|
✅Yes, create ticket
Yes, 8AM - 7PM IST, Monday - Saturday
✅Yes, Chat support |
Leverage (Margin) Offered
| |
|
Equity Delivery Margin Leverage
|
No leverage available; requires full margin upfront
No leverage available; you need the full purchase value in your account.
No leverage available; you need the full purchase value in your account. |
|
Equity Intraday Margin Leverage
|
Upto 5x depending on the stock (lower leverage for volatile stocks)
Leverage ranges from 1x to 5x depending on the stock (lower leverage for volatile stocks)
Upto 5x depending on the stock (lower leverage for volatile stocks) |
|
Equity F&O Intraday Margin Leverage
|
No leverage available; requires full margin upfront
Leverage is 1.3x across all Equity F&O contracts
No leverage available; you need the full purchase value in your account. |
|
Equity F&O Carry Forward Margin Leverage
|
No leverage available; requires full margin upfront
No leverage available; requires full margin upfront
No leverage available; you need the full purchase value in your account. |
|
Currency F&O Margin Leverage
|
No leverage available; requires full margin upfront
Leverage is 1.3x across all Currency F&O contracts
No leverage available; you need the full purchase value in your account. |
|
Commodity F&O Intraday Margin Leverage
|
No leverage available; requires full margin upfront
Leverage is 1.3x across all Commodity F&O contracts
No leverage available; you need the full purchase value in your account. |
|
Commodity F&O Carry Forward Margin Leverage
|
No leverage available; requires full margin upfront
No leverage available; requires full margin upfront
No leverage available; you need the full purchase value in your account. |
Unique Offerings
| |
|
Free Account Opening
|
✅Yes
✅Yes
✅Yes |
|
Free Brokerage
|
✅Yes, but with Ultra Trader (₹1199 per month)
On Mutual Funds and IPOs only
✅Yes |
|
Free AMC
|
⛔No
✅Yes
✅Yes |
|
Free Equity Delivery
|
✅Yes, but with Ultra Trader (₹1199 per month)
⛔No
✅Yes |
|
Free F&O Trading
|
⛔No
⛔No
✅Yes |
|
Free Intraday Trading
|
✅Yes, but with Ultra Trader (₹1199 per month)
⛔No
✅Yes |
|
Free Trading calls
|
₹100
⛔No
⛔No |
|
Happy Trading Hours
|
⛔No
⛔No
⛔No |
|
Flexible Brokerage Plans
|
✅Yes
⛔No
✅Yes |
|
Referral Offers
|
✅Yes
✅Yes
✅Yes |
|
Margin Funding (MTF)/ Pledging
|
✅Yes
✅Yes
⛔No |
|
Brokerage Cashback
|
⛔No
⛔No
⛔No |
|
Zero Brokerage for Loss Making Trades
|
⛔No
⛔No
⛔No |
|
Relationship Manager
|
⛔No
⛔No
⛔No |
Services Provided
| |
|
Equity Delivery
|
✅Yes
✅Yes
✅Yes |
|
Equity Intraday
|
✅Yes
✅Yes
✅Yes |
|
Equity Futures
|
✅Yes
✅Yes
✅Yes |
|
Equity Options
|
✅Yes
✅Yes
✅Yes |
|
Currency Futures
|
✅Yes
✅Yes
✅Yes |
|
Currency Options
|
✅Yes
✅Yes
✅Yes |
|
Commodity Futures
|
✅Yes
✅Yes
✅Yes |
|
Commodity Options
|
✅Yes
✅Yes
✅Yes |
|
Foreign Stocks
|
✅Yes, with Vested
⛔No
⛔No |
|
Mutual Funds
|
✅Yes
✅Yes
✅Yes |
|
Banking
|
⛔No
⛔No
⛔No |
|
Insurance
|
⛔No
⛔No
⛔No |
|
Corporate Bonds
|
⛔No
⛔No
⛔No |
|
Govt. Bonds
|
✅Yes
⛔No
⛔No |
|
Digital Gold
|
⛔No
⛔No
⛔No |
Order Types
| |
|
Market Order
|
✅Yes
✅Yes
✅Yes |
|
Limit Order
|
✅Yes
✅Yes
✅Yes |
|
Bracket Order
|
✅Yes
✅Yes
✅Yes |
|
Cover Order
|
✅Yes
✅Yes
✅Yes |
|
After Market Order (AMO)
|
✅Yes
✅Yes
✅Yes |
|
Good Till Cancelled (GTC)
|
✅Yes
✅Yes
✅Yes |
|
Buy Today Sell Tomorrow (BTST)
|
✅Yes
⛔No
⛔No |
|
Sell Today Buy Tomorrow (STBT)
|
✅Yes
⛔No
⛔No |
Research & Reports
| |
|
Annual Reports
|
✅Yes
⛔No
⛔No |
|
Company Reports
|
✅Yes
✅Yes, Basic only
⛔No |
|
Research Reports
|
⛔No
⛔No
⛔No |
|
Fundamental Reports
|
✅Yes
✅Yes, Basic only
⛔No |
|
IPO Reports
|
✅Yes
✅Yes
✅Yes |
|
Technical Reports
|
⛔No
✅Yes, Basic only
⛔No |
|
Stock tips
|
✅Yes
⛔No
⛔No |
|
Daily Market Review
|
✅Yes
✅Yes
✅Yes |
|
Monthly Review
|
✅Yes
✅Yes
⛔No |
|
Weekly Review
|
✅Yes
✅Yes
⛔No |
|
Robo Advisory
|
⛔No
⛔No
⛔No |
STT & CTT Charges
| |
|
Equity Delivery STT & CTT
|
0.1% on Buy & Sell
0.1% on buy & sell
0.1% on buy & sell |
|
Equity Intraday STT & CTT
|
0.025% on the sell side
0.025% on the sell side
0.025% on the sell side |
|
Equity Futures STT & CTT
|
0.0125% on the sell side
0.0125% on sell side
0.0125% on sell side |
|
Equity Options STT & CTT
|
0.0625% on sell side (on premium)
0.0625% on sell side (on premium)
0.0625% on sell side (on premium) |
|
Currency Futures STT & CTT
|
No STT
No STT
No STT |
|
Currency Options STT & CTT
|
No STT
No STT
No STT |
|
Commodity Futures STT & CTT
|
0.01% on sell side (Non-Agri)
0.01% on sell trade (Non-Agri)
0.01% (of Selling Value) |
|
Commodity Options STT & CTT
|
0.05% on sell side
0.05% on sell trade
0.05% (of Selling Value) |
Trading Features
| |
|
Watchlist
|
✅Yes
✅Yes
✅Yes |
|
Real Time Updates
|
✅Yes
✅Yes
✅Yes |
|
Portfolio Details
|
✅Yes
✅Yes
✅Yes |
|
Price Alert
|
✅Yes
✅Yes
✅Yes |
|
Online Mutual Fund Buy
|
✅Yes
✅Yes
✅Yes |
|
Global indices
|
⛔No
⛔No
⛔No |
|
Customized Recommendations
|
⛔No
⛔No
⛔No |
|
Advanced charting
|
✅Yes
✅Yes
✅Yes |
|
Live market
|
✅Yes
✅Yes
✅Yes |
|
Multiple Profile Management
|
⛔No
⛔No
⛔No |
|
Secure Platform
|
✅Yes
✅Yes
✅Yes |
Trading Platforms
| |
|
Android App
|
✅Yes
✅Yes
✅Yes |
|
iOS App
|
✅Yes
✅Yes
✅Yes |
|
Web Trading Platform
|
✅Yes
✅Yes
✅Yes |
|
Trading Terminal
|
✅Yes
✅Yes
✅Yes |
|
Algo Trading Platform
|
✅Yes
✅Yes
✅Yes |
|
Foreign Stocks Trading Platform
|
✅Yes
⛔No
⛔No |
|
Basket Trading Platform
|
✅Yes
✅Yes
✅Yes |
|
Mutual Fund Investment Platform
|
✅Yes
✅Yes
✅Yes |
|
Digital Gold Investment Platform
|
⛔No
⛔No
⛔No |
|
Bonds Investment Platform
|
✅Yes
⛔No
⛔No |
Transaction Charges
| |
|
Equity Delivery Transaction Charges
|
NSE: 0.00325% | BSE: 0.00375%
NSE 0.00325% per trade on buy & sell. BSE charges vary as per the scrip group
0.00325% |
|
Equity Intraday Transaction Charges
|
NSE: 0.00325% | BSE: 0.00375%
NSE: 0.00325% per trade on buy & sell. BSE charges vary as per the scrip group
0.00325% |
|
Equity Futures Transaction Charges
|
NSE: 0.0019% | BSE: 0
NSE Exchange turnover charge: 0.0019%. BSE: Nil
Exchange txn charge: 0.0019% |
|
Equity Options Transaction Charges
|
NSE: 0.05% (on premium) | BSE: 0.0325% (on premium)
NSE Exchange turnover charge: 0.050% (on premium). BSE: 0.0375% (on premium)
Exchange txn charge: 0.05% (on premium) |
|
Currency Futures Transaction Charges
|
0.0009%
NSE: Exchange txn charge: 0.0009% & BSE: Exchange txn charge: 0.00022%
Exchange txn charge: 0.0009% |
|
Currency Options Transaction Charges
|
NSE: Exchange txn charge: 0.035% | BSE: Exchange txn charge: 0.001%
NSE: Exchange txn charge: 0.035% & BSE: Exchange txn charge: 0.001%
Exchange txn charge: 0.035% |
|
Commodity Futures Transaction Charges
|
Exchange txn charge: 0.0026%
Non-Agri: Exchange turnover charge: 0.0026%
260/ crore |
|
Commodity Options Transaction Charges
|
Exchange txn charge: 0.05%
Exchange turnover charge: 0.05%
5000/ crore |
Stamp Duty charges
| |
|
Equity Delivery Stamp Duty
|
0.015% or ₹1500 / crore on buy side
0.015% or ₹1500 / crore on buy side
0.015% |
|
Equity Intraday Stamp Duty
|
0.003% or ₹300 / crore on buy side
0.003% or ₹300 / crore on buy side
0.003% |
|
Equity Futures Stamp Duty
|
0.002% or ₹200 / crore on buy side
0.002% or ₹200 / crore on buy side
0.002% |
|
Equity Options Stamp Duty
|
0.003% or ₹300 / crore on buy side
0.003% or ₹300 / crore on buy side
0.003% |
|
Currency Futures Stamp Duty
|
0.0001% or ₹10 / crore on buy side
0.0001% or Rs 10 per crore on buy-side
0.0001% on Buy Side |
|
Currency Options Stamp Duty
|
0.0001% or ₹10 / crore on buy side
0.0001% or Rs 10 per crore on buy-side
0.0001% on Buy Side |
|
Commodity Futures Stamp Duty
|
0.002% or ₹200 / crore on buy side
0.002% or ₹200 per crore on buy-side
0.002% |
|
Commodity Options Stamp Duty
|
0.003% or ₹300 / crore on buy side
0.003% or ₹300 per crore on buy-side
0.003% |
Other Charges
| |
|
SEBI Turnover Charges
|
₹10 / crore
₹10/crore (For all segments)
₹10/Crore (For all segments) |
|
DP Charges
|
₹12.5 + GST per scrip
₹18.5 + GST per scrip (irrespective of quantity)
₹9 + GST/scrip |
|
GST charges
|
18% of (Brokerage + Transaction charges + Demat)
18% of (brokerage + transaction charges + Demat)
18% of (brokerage + transaction charges + Demat) |
|
Account Closure Charges
|
Free
Free
Free |
|
Reactivation Charges
|
Free
Free
Free |
|
Dematerialization Charges
|
₹15 per certificate + ₹40 for postal charges
₹20 per Certificate
₹150 per certificate + ₹100 courier charges |
|
Call and Trade charges
|
₹100
₹50 + 18% GST
₹0 |
